A good eye-shadow palette is essential for highlighting and defining your eyes, whether you prefer a laid-back wash of color over your lids or you’re experimenting with head-turning cut creases.

Ahead, two celebrity makeup artists weigh in on everything you need to know about lip crayons—plus, the best products to shop.

But the best eyeshadows for older women will be hydrating and soothing, like these, which have glycerin, hyaluronic acid, alpine rose, and coconut water to prevent the shadow from falling into ...